IN RE VEHICLE CARRIER SERVICES ANTITRUST LITIGATION

Master Docket No. 13-3306 (ES), MDL No. 2471.

IN RE VEHICLE CARRIER SERVICES ANTITRUST LITIGATION. This Document Relates To All Actions

United States District Court, D. New Jersey.

August 28, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

F. RUGGIERO & SONS, INC., Plaintiff, represented by HOLLIS LEE SALZMAN , ROBINS KAPLAN LLP, JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C., MEEGAN F. HOLLYWOOD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, WARREN T BURNS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & DANIEL H. CHAREST , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

ROBERT O'ROURKE, Plaintiff, represented by HOLLIS LEE SALZMAN , ROBINS KAPLAN LLP, JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C., MEEGAN F. HOLLYWOOD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, WARREN T BURNS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & DANIEL H. CHAREST , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Martens Cars of Washington, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, BRIAN K. HERRINGTON , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KELLY MAGNUS PURCARO , Cohn Lifland Pearlman Herrman & Knopf, LLP.

Hudson Charleston Acquisition, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

HUDSON NISSAN, Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

John O'Neil Johnson Toyota, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Hudson Gastonia Acquisition, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

HC ACQUISITIONS, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Toyota of Bristol, Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Desert European Motorcars, Ltd., Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BENJAMIN DAVID ELGA , CUNEO GILBERT & LADUCA LLP, DANIEL COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JONATHAN WATSON CUNEO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KATHERINE WARREN VAN DYCK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSPORT MANAGEMENT CORP., Plaintiff, represented by EUGENE A. SPECTOR , SPECTOR, ROSEMAN KODROFF & WILLIS, PC, JOSEPH J. DEPALMA , LITE, DEPALMA, GREENBERG, LLC, MICHAEL E. MOSKOVITZ , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, RACHEL ELLEN KOPP , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, STEVEN A. KANNER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, LAUREN E. FENTON-VALDIVIA , BRESSLER, AMERY & ROSS, P.C., LEE ALBERT , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, LEWIS HARRY GOLDFARB , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & ROBERT P. DONOVAN , MCELROY DEUTSCH MULVANEY & CARPENTER, LLP.

Antonio Maravilla, Plaintiff, represented by REGINALD VON TERRELL , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Joan MacQuarrie, Plaintiff, represented by ALEXANDER E BARNETT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ELIZABETH C. PRITZKER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ELIZABETH TRAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, STEVEN N. WILLIAMS , COTCHETT PITRE & MCCARTHY LLP & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Brenda Keegan, Plaintiff, represented by ALEXANDER E BARNETT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ELIZABETH C. PRITZKER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ELIZABETH TRAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & STEVEN N. WILLIAMS , COTCHETT PITRE & MCCARTHY LLP.

Cargo Agents, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by LAUREN ILENE DUBICK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & ROBERT N. KAPLAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

DODA CAMAJ, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C., PAUL F NOVAK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & DIANA GJONAJ , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

TONY NIKPRELAJ, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C., PAUL F NOVAK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & DIANA GJONAJ , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

BETHANNE KNUDSON, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

ESTEBAN ADAME, Plaintiff, represented by BRIAN RUSSELL STRANGE , STRANGE & CARPENTER, KEITH L. BUTLER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, PAUL J. GELLER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & STUART A. DAVIDSON , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO THE USCD.

KENNETH A. NELSON, Plaintiff, represented by Arthur M. Murray , Murray Law Firm, Charles D. Gabriel , Pierce Gabriel Partners, LLC, DANIEL H. CHAREST , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Douglas D. Chunn , Douglas D. Chunn, PA, ISAAC L DIEL , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, Robert L. Devereux , Devereux Murphy LLC, STEPHEN B. MURRAY, JR , MURRAY LAW FIRM, Samuel P. Pierce, Jr. , Pierce Gabriel Partners, LLC, Terry Oxford , Susman Godfrey, LLP & WARREN T BURNS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

RITA DIEL-BROWN, Plaintiff, represented by Arthur M. Murray , Murray Law Firm, Charles D. Gabriel , Pierce Gabriel Partners, LLC, DANIEL H. CHAREST , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Douglas D. Chunn , Douglas D. Chunn, PA, ISAAC L DIEL , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, Joseph F. Devereux , Devereux Murphy LLC & KOREY A. NELSON , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

EUGENE THOMAS GOESSLING, Plaintiff, represented by Arthur M. Murray , Murray Law Firm, Charles D. Gabriel , Pierce Gabriel Partners, LLC, DANIEL H. CHAREST , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Douglas D. Chunn , Douglas D. Chunn, PA, ISAAC L DIEL , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C., Joseph F. Devereux , Devereux Murphy LLC & KOREY A. NELSON , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

PAMELA E. GOESSLING, Plaintiff, represented by Arthur M. Murray , Murray Law Firm, Charles D. Gabriel , Pierce Gabriel Partners, LLC, DANIEL H. CHAREST , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Douglas D. Chunn , Douglas D. Chunn, PA, ISAAC L DIEL , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC NJ BAR, JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C., Joseph F. Devereux , Devereux Murphy LLC & KOREY A. NELSON , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

DAVID SCHROEDER, Plaintiff, represented by BETSY CAROL MANIFOLD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & FRANCIS M. GREGOREK , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

ALEX WHITE, Plaintiff, represented by Linda G Workman , Dicks and Workman APC.

INTERESTED PARTY, Plaintiff, represented by FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA.

MANACO INTERNATIONAL FORWARDERS, INC., Plaintiff, represented by CHARLES ANDREW DIRKSEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DOUGLAS A. ABRAHAMS , KOHN, SWIFT, & GRAF, PC, Gregory P. Hansel , Preti Flaherty Beliveau Pachios & Haley, LLP, John Douglas Richards , Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC, Joseph C. Kohn , Kohn, Swift, & Graf, P.C., KIT A. PIERSON , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, MICHAEL BENJAMIN EISENKRAFT , COHEN MILSTEIN SELLERS & TOLL PC, DAVID A. YOUNG , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, MANUEL JUAN DOMINGUEZ , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & MATTHEW W. RUAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSPORT MANAGEMENT CORP., Plaintiff, represented by Albert J. Pucciarelli , LAUREN E. FENTON-VALDIVIA , BRESSLER, AMERY & ROSS, P.C., LEE ALBERT , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP & LEWIS HARRY GOLDFARB , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

ROSS STASIK, Plaintiff, represented by BETSY CAROL MANIFOLD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & Randall S. Newman , Randall S. Newman PC.

ADAIR LARA, Plaintiff, represented by Adam C. Belsky , Gross Belsky Alonso LLP, Monique Alonso , Gross & Belsky LLP, Sarah Crowley , Gross Belsky Alonso LLP, TERRY GROSS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

KATHLEEN C. DAVIS, Plaintiff, represented by GUIDO SAVERI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & R. Alexander Saveri , Saveri & Saveri, Inc..

SEAN SPICER, Plaintiff, represented by STEVEN N. WILLIAMS , COTCHETT PITRE & MCCARTHY LLP.

PHYLLIS ROSEN, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

GUSTAVO ADOLFO PEREZ, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

JENNIFER FROZENA, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

ASHTON LEVIS, Plaintiff, represented by AUSTIN B COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Adam John Zapala , Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy LLP & ELIZABETH TRAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

BRUCE HERTZ, Plaintiff, represented by AUSTIN B COHEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Adam John Zapala , Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy LLP, ELIZABETH TRAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

LAZARO VERSALLES, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL C. HEDLUND , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DIANNE M. NAST , NastLaw LLC, Erin Cathleen Burns , NastLaw LLC & Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

MATTHEW HEILICHER, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

ELIZABETH POWERS KELLER, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

ERIC L. METH, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

JEFF RUBINSTEIN, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

JUDY A. REIBER, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER THOMAS MICHELETTI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIEL R. SHULMAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

CRAIG BUSKE, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER THOMAS MICHELETTI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIEL R. SHULMAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

ELIZABETH ALLIS, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER THOMAS MICHELETTI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIEL R. SHULMAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA.

WILLIAM ELWOOD, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER THOMAS MICHELETTI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIEL R. SHULMAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA.

DARREL SENIOR, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER THOMAS MICHELETTI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA.

MATTHEW RIGHETTI, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER THOMAS MICHELETTI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA.

TIFFANY BUI, Plaintiff, represented by Scott M Grzenczyk , Girard Gibbs LLP.

NICHOLAS LETOURNEAU, Plaintiff, represented by Scott M Grzenczyk , Girard Gibbs LLP.

KATRINA BONAR, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

STEVEN BRUZONSKY, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

LORI CURTIS, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

JENNIFER DILLON, Plaintiff, represented by ALYSON LOUISE OLIVER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

SHERYL HALEY, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

SHARON HAMPSON, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

DANIEL MORRIS, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

PAULA OCHSNER, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

JUDY SMITH, Plaintiff, represented by Steven Noel Williams , Cotchett Pitre & McCarthy LLP.

MICHAEL JACKSON, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER LOVELL , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, CHRISTOPHER THOMAS MICHELETTI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & FRANCIS ONOFREI SCARPULLA , LAW OFFICES OF FRANCIS O. SCARPULLA.

EMILY FERRIS, Plaintiff, represented by Jack Wing Lee , Minami Tamaki LLP & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

TOM WARE, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Jack Wing Lee , Minami Tamaki LLP & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

ALAN FRONT, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

MARY G. BISSEN, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

GREG DANA, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

JOE GROJEAN, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

JERRY DAVID, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

WILDA J. NIN-PACHECO, Plaintiff, represented by SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

RITA M. CLOWARD, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

DIANE DAVID, Plaintiff, represented by DEREK G. HOWARD , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, Jack Wing Lee , Minami Tamaki LLP & SEAN TAMIO TAMURA-SATO , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

CRYSTAL BOYKIN, Plaintiff, represented by CRYSTAL BOYKIN PRO SE

TUAN NGUYEN, Plaintiff, represented by Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

TUAN NGUYEN, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser & Timothy D. Battin , Straus & Boies LLP.

EMPIRE NISSAN OF SANTA ROSA, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

HODGES IMPORTED CARS, INC d/b/a HODGES SUBARU, Plaintiff, represented by PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

PANAMA CITY AUTOMOTIVE GROUP, INC d/b/a JOHN LEE NISSAN, Plaintiff, represented by PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

Melinda Deneau, Plaintiff, represented by Melinda Deneau PRO SE.

Jill M. Alban, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Grant M. Alban, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Al Baker, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Emmett Brophy, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Monica Brushey, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Melinda Deneau, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Jennifer Dillon, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

JEFFREY GANNON, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Sean Gurney, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Leslie Denise Hart, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Elizabeth Ashley Hill, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Maria Kooker, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Christie Laster, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Kori Lehrkamp, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

John Leyva, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Joan MacQuarrie, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Roberta Rothsetin, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Alexandra Scott, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

CATHERINE TAYLOR, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

Richard Tomasko, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & ROBERT J. BONSIGNORE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Demian Vargas, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

MARY ARNOLD, Plaintiff, represented by ANNE T. REGAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DAVID M. CIALKOWSKI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

STEPHANIE B. CROSBY, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF ARIZONA, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF CALIFORNIA, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF COLORADO, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF FLORIDA, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF GEORGIA, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF IDAHO, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF KANSAS, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF NORTH CAROLINA, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF OHIO, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF OKLAHOMA, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF TEXAS, LP., Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF UTAH, INC.,, Plaintiff, represented by ERIC R. BRESLIN , DUANE MORRIS, LLP.

SCOTLAND CAR YARD ENTERPRISES d/b/a SAN RAFAEL MITSUBISHI, Plaintiff, represented by PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

HARTLEY BUICK/GMC TRUCK, INC. d/b/a HARTLEY HONDA, Plaintiff, represented by PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

JOSHUA SO, Plaintiff, represented by NOAH M. SCHUBERT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Automobile Dealership Plaintiffs, Plaintiff, represented by GERARD V. MANTESE , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

GENERAL MOTORS LLC, Plaintiff, represented by CHAHIRA SOLH , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIEL A. SASSE , CROWELL & MORING, ELIZABETH ANNE FIGUEIRA , CROWELL AND MORING LLP & RYAN CHRISTOPHER WONG , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

PENDRELL JACKSON, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & PETER GEORGE SAFIRSTEIN , MORGAN & MORGAN.

NYK LINE (NORTH AMERICA) INC., Defendant, represented by ERIC R. FISH , BAKER HOSTETLER LLP & JOHN R. FORNACIARI , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

NIPPON YUSEN KABUSHIKI KAISHA, Defendant, represented by NIPPON YUSEN KABUSHIKI KAISHA PRO SE.

WILH WILHELMSEN HOLDING ASA, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR, JASON ALLEN LECKERMAN , BALLARD SPAHR LLP & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

WILH WILHELMSEN ASA, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR, JASON ALLEN LECKERMAN , BALLARD SPAHR LLP & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

MITSUI O.S.K. LINES, LTD.,, Defendant, represented by ADAM MICHAEL PERGAMENT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ANNE P. DAVIS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIELLE M. GARTEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES L. COOPER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

"K" LINE AMERICA, INC., Defendant, represented by JEREMY JAMES CALSYN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, MARK W. NELSON , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, MICHAEL R. LAZERWITZ , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & STEVEN JOHN KAISER , CLEARY GOTTLIEB STEEN & HAMILTON LLP.

EUKOR VEHICLE CARRIERS INC., Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR, JASON ALLEN LECKERMAN , BALLARD SPAHR LLP & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

WALLENIUS WILHELMSEN LOGISTICS AS, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR, JASON ALLEN LECKERMAN , BALLARD SPAHR LLP & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

WALLENIUS WILHELMSEN LOGISTICS AMERICAS LLC, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR, JASON ALLEN LECKERMAN , BALLARD SPAHR LLP & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

WALLENIUS LINES AB, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR, JASON ALLEN LECKERMAN , BALLARD SPAHR LLP & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

COMPANIA SUD AMERICANA DE VAPORES S.A., Defendant, represented by STEVEN F. CHERRY , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & TODD F. BRAUNSTEIN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

TOYOFUJI SHIPPING CO. LTD., Defendant, represented by JOHN CLAYTON EVERETT, JR. , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

NISSAN MOTOR CAR CARRIER CO., LTD, Defendant, represented by ADAM MICHAEL PERGAMENT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ANNE P. DAVIS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIELLE M. GARTEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES L. COOPER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

WWL Vehicle Services Americas Inc., Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

American Shipping and Logistics Inc., Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

American Roll-On Roll-Off Carrier, LLC, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

American Auto Logistics, LP, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN F. HOLT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & MAXIM M.L. NOWAK , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

Mitsui O.S.K. Bulk Shipping (U.S.A.), Inc., Defendant, represented by ADAM MICHAEL PERGAMENT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ANNE P. DAVIS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIELLE M. GARTEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES L. COOPER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

MOL (AMERICA), INC., Defendant, represented by ADAM MICHAEL PERGAMENT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIELLE M. GARTEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES L. COOPER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

MOL Logistics (USA), Inc., Defendant, represented by ADAM MICHAEL PERGAMENT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIELLE M. GARTEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & JAMES L. COOPER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

World Logistics Service (U.S.A.), Inc., Defendant, represented by ADAM MICHAEL PERGAMENT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, ANNE P. DAVIS , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIELLE M. GARTEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JAMES L. COOPER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR.

World Transport Co. Ltd., Defendant, represented by ADAM MICHAEL PERGAMENT , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, DANIELLE M. GARTEN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC, JAMES L. COOPER , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & ROBERTO A. RIVERA-SOTO , BALLARD SPAHR.

CSAV AGENCY, LLC, Defendant, represented by STEVEN F. CHERRY , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & TODD F. BRAUNSTEIN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC.

Hoegh Autoliners AS (Norway), Defendant, represented by MELISSA HELEN MAXMAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KEVIN MICHAEL KELLY , COZEN O'CONNOR.

Hoegh Autoliners, Inc. (US), Defendant, represented by MELISSA HELEN MAXMAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KEVIN MICHAEL KELLY , COZEN O'CONNOR.

Hoegh Autoliners AS (Norway), Defendant, represented by MELISSA HELEN MAXMAN , COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC & KEVIN MICHAEL KELLY , COZEN O'CONNOR.


OPINION

I. INTRODUCTION

In this multidistrict litigation ("MDL"), purchasers of vehicle carrier services allege a conspiracy among ocean shipping companies to fix prices, allocate customers and routes, and restrict capacity. Direct Purchaser Plaintiffs ("DPPs") filed a consolidated class action complaint...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases