In 2018, the Guardian quoted the mayor of Pontevedra in Spain about the decision to make the city center car-free: “The historical center was dead… There were a lot of drugs, it was full of cars — it was a marginal zone.” To save the city, at first the city planners tried to address the problem of traffic, but then they decided to simply get rid of cars.
The results have been spectacular. The city itself is widely regarded as a model among car-free cities, with numerous studies devoted to aspects of its experience. After the city went car-free, the downtown population jumped. As of 2018, there had been no traffic deaths since 2009. The mayor was elected four more times.
Taiwan should be paying attention.
Photo: Tu Chien-jung, Taipei Times
BENEFITS OF GOING CAR-FREE
Most of the benefits of car-free cities are well known. For example, Taiwan usually has over 400 pedestrian deaths annually. If our careless drivers became car-less, those numbers would fall.
Greater livability? Lower noise and air pollution? Increased health and vitality of the residents and the spaces they move about in? The experience of car-free cities around the world attests to these benefits.
Photo courtesy of the Tainan Tourism Bureau
Denizens of car-free environments also experience improved social interactions, a benefit to all, but especially to the oft-neglected elderly. The massive increase in walking and cycling that ensues leads to lower CO2 levels, also an effect of denser urban spaces. Suburbs kept alive by cars are carbon nightmares.
But there are other effects that might warm Taiwanese hearts. Reduced air pollution is associated not only with health benefits but better cognitive performance. For children, that means better school performance. Traffic noise is associated with depression, anxiety and suicide. Our cars are killing us in countless ways.
Studies show that one of the most common reasons for traffic congestion is cars searching for a place to park, an inevitability in Taiwan’s cramped streets. That lack of space also drives scooters up on the sidewalk to park and drive, there to injure thousands of pedestrians annually.
Photo: Chen Yen-ting, Taipei Times
Taiwan’s mom-and-pop stores have been relentlessly killed by convenience stores. Taiwanese consumers hate walking, and prefer to bounce quickly in and out of the store, because they are rushing to and from their 60-90 minute commutes.
Revitalized downtowns would help address this issue, especially in older areas crowded with small, family-owned storefronts. A New York City Department of Transportation study found that retail sales rose 49 percent on 9th Avenue after a protected bike lane was put in. A study last year by analysts at Yelp showed that consumers showed greater interest in restaurant areas that were temporarily without cars due to pandemic restrictions.
A bank analysis of car-free areas in Madrid found not only a 9.5 percent increase in retail sales in areas with significant car restrictions, but a city-wide increase of 3.3 percent. Car-free is so powerful, even areas with cars benefit.
Such data should help assuage fears that businesses would lose out if cars disappeared.
Taiwan is almost ideal for a car-free switch, with its high-speed rail line and extensive train and bus network. Moreover, the nation’s towns and cities almost all host small, dense city centers with small storefronts, all potentially very walkable.
PILOT PROGRAMS
Car-free cities would be possible in many of Taiwan’s satellite towns and in the crowded, built-up areas around train stations. Pontevedra has a population of just over 80,000. Smaller, older towns with cramped city centers, like Fengshan (鳳山) in Kaohsiung and Fengyuan (豐原) in Taichung, would make ideal candidates for pilot programs.
Fengyuan even has two layers of ring roads, the second a barren four-lane concrete ribbon whose obvious purpose is forwarding the developmentalist ideal that cities exist only as destinations for cars. The infrastructure and space for parking lots outside the city, as in Pontevedra, already exist. The railroad station is right in the center of town. Perfect.
In the last few decades the government has completed bypasses that run major roads around many smaller communities like Changbin (長濱) in Taitung and Yuanli (苑裡) in Miaoli, instead of through them. Since such towns are small and easily walkable, it would not be difficult to pilot car-free areas in them, yet permit easy access from the bypass roads.
Taitung city itself would be ideal, save for the poorly-located train station. The city center can be walked across in 20 minutes.
One could easily imagine expanded programs that take in cities like Tainan and Hsinchu. It’s a delight to walk through the area north of the train station in Hsinchu even with its current traffic levels. If the area between the train station and the City God Temple were freed of cars, it would be an urban paradise.
POPULATION BOOST
Another benefit that areas that go car-free often experience is a population boost. Miaoli, Taitung and other rural and mountainous areas are losing population to the cities. One way to address that issue might be to go car-free. Older small towns in those areas, like Yujing (玉井) in Tainan with its 15,000 people or Yuli (玉里) in Hualien (pop. 25,000) would make great places to experiment with a car-free downtown.
Miaoli city, with 87,000 people, is quite comparable to Pontevedra. The city center is only a few kilometers across, easily walkable. The point on the escarpment where the 13 peaks above the city offers staggering views. Amazingly, no one seems to have proposed a gondola for that, a place that could actually use one (having proposed one, I am now officially eligible to run for the local city council). Probably because — you guessed it — there is no room with four lanes of ugly concrete there.
In the mid-2000s, the government sprinkled artist villages around Taiwan, a transparent attempt to summon into being by policy what was not growing organically. Such villages were nice, but they lacked the supportive atmosphere of walkable districts full of cafes, bookshops, restaurants and, above all, open and safe public spaces for socializing and performance.
Car-free promises all that.
Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.
On Facebook a friend posted a dashcam video of a vehicle driving through the ash-colored wasteland of what was once Taroko Gorge. A crane appears in the video, and suddenly it becomes clear: the video is in color, not black and white. The magnitude 7.2 earthquake’s destruction on April 3 around and above Taroko and its reverberations across an area heavily dependent on tourism have largely vanished from the international press discussions as the news cycle moves on, but local residents still live with its consequences every day. For example, with the damage to the road corridors between Yilan and
May 13 to May 19 While Taiwanese were eligible to take the Qing Dynasty imperial exams starting from 1686, it took more than a century for a locally-registered scholar to pass the highest levels and become a jinshi (進士). In 1823, Hsinchu City resident Cheng Yung-hsi (鄭用錫) traveled to Beijing and accomplished the feat, returning home in great glory. There were technically three Taiwan residents who did it before Cheng, but two were born in China and remained registered in their birthplaces, while historians generally discount the third as he changed his residency back to Fujian Province right after the exams.
Few scenes are more representative of rural Taiwan than a mountain slope covered in row upon row of carefully manicured tea plants. Like staring at the raked sand in a Zen garden, seeing these natural features in an unnaturally perfect arrangement of parallel lines has a certain calming effect. Snapping photos of the tea plantations blanketing Taiwan’s mountain is a favorite activity among tourists but, unfortunately, the experience is often rather superficial. As these tea fields are part of working farms, it’s not usually possible to walk amongst them or sample the teas they are producing, much less understand how the
With William Lai’s (賴清德) presidential inauguration coming up on May 20, both sides of the Taiwan Strait have been signaling each other, possibly about re-opening lines of communication. For that to happen, there are two ways this could happen, one very difficult to achieve and the other dangerous. During his presidential campaign and since Lai has repeatedly expressed his hope to re-establish communication based on equality and mutual respect, and even said he hoped to meet with Chinese leader Xi Jinping (習近平) over beef noodles and bubble tea. More dramatically, as explored in the May 2 edition of this column,