IN RE BRICAN AMERICA LLC, EQUIPMENT LEASE LITIGATION

Case No. 10-md-02183-PAS.

IN RE: Brican America LLC, Equipment Lease Litigation.

United States District Court, S.D. Florida.

July 18, 2014.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Stephen G. Blank DDS, PA, a Florida professional association, Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Roarke Miller, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jeffrey Klein, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Duey Handy, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Dobson, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fredrick Cloninger, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Erick Gray, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Marc Flesher, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Janiene Gresla, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Mormon, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Angel Lopez, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Pedro Mora-Rosa, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Robert Heinrich, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alan Baribeau, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Francine Camporeale, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Miffleton, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ross Palioca, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Rasbornik, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

David Discher, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Richard Norman, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joel David, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Philippe Morisseau, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Frank Paletta, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ali Sarkarzadeh, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Terry Friedman, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Clark, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Douglas Machiela, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Enrico Core, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jeffrey Riso, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Justin Chien, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John Brown, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fred Grimes, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Norman Dery, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gregory Hom, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Rafael Palanganas, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Daniel Mashoof, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Donald Newman, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Adelaida Guarin, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Albert Arcand, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Edward Chermol, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Lisa Peters, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dirk Hagen, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Barry Rosenberg, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Miguel Pulido, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Nicholas Papapetros, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gilbert Principe, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Behdad Omrani, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Flugrad, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gerry Casazza, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Aaron Collins, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Carmine Morreale, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael W Wells, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Amir Khoshnevis, Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Shaun Larsen, Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Peter M. Blauzvern DDS PC, a New York professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jeff E. Donnelly, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

John M. Highsmith, DDS, PA, a North Carolina professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Steven B Oken, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Justin Chang, PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David Alemar DMD, PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jeffrey S Thaller, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Kenneth A. Korpan DDS, PC, an Illinois professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Michael S Burstein, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Charles H Estelle, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Stuart A Curry, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Gary Lederman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Brian A. McMurtry, DDS, PA, a North Carolina professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Dr. Chandra R. Williams DMD, LLC, a Georgia limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Geoffrey S. Wozar, DMD, PC, a Pennsylvania professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jennifer Goldman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Amy Thu Tran, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Mountain Lakes Dental Associates, PA, a New Jersey professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Peter K Eng, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Eye-Deal Family Eye Care, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David Archibald, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Paul Taylor DMD, Inc., a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Arthur B. Silver DDS PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

John C. Sieweke DDS PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

John C Sieweke, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Amarilis Jacobo, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Stephen R Kepley, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Mark Margolies, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

George C. Weeks DDS PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

George C Weeks, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Alan M Rapoport, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Raymond Goodman, OD, PA, an Idaho professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Raymond Goodman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Cary Family Eye Care, OD, PA, a North Carolina professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Dwight W Barnes, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Steven J Luccarelli, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Stanely D. Halpern, DDS, PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Stanley D Halpern, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Webster Cosmetic Dental Ltd., an Illinois limited company, d/b/a Webster Cosmetic Dental, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Barbara K. Webster, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Eric Smith, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David S. Lee, DDS, Inc., a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David S Lee, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Stone Creek Dental, PC, an Idaho professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Casey S Butterfield, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Carolina Family Vision, OD, PA, a North Carolina professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Adam B Bryan, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Kristy L Tart-Bryan, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Peter Epstein DMD PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Peter Epstein, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Christopher Young DMD PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Christopher Young, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Chadds Ford Dental Associates, Inc., a Pennsylvania corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Andrew Pratt, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

J.M. Arrue DMD LLC, a Georgia limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

J M Arrue, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Troy R. Lindh DMD PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Troy R Lindh, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Brian G DePetris, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Gordon Bell, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Benjamin Gamm, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Eyexam Associates, PA, a New Jersey professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Elizabeth Lewis, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Kelly L Kalmar, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Kalmar Family Dentistry, LLP, a New York limited liability partnership, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Henderson Mill Dental Care, PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

John H Mason, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Eric S Smith, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Robert R Thousand, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Lumberton Optometric Associates, PLLC, a North Carolina professional limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Charles E Scholler, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Marc B Nelson, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Michael E. and Maria Domingoes, PA, a Florida professional association, doing business as Anastasia Dental Associates, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Todd J Feddock, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Visual Perceptions Eyecare, LLC, a Connecticut limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Geoffrey A Banga, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Christine Nguyen, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Han Hong, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Dentistry at Vinings, PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Peter D Maro, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Daniel Casel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Bruce Corbin, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Sid Morse, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Paul M Hertz, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Larry J Moray, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Deogsoo Roh, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Farid Hanachi DDS PA, a North Carolina corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

J Randall Glass, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Richard E Sorkin, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Ginger Coley, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Joseph R. Kenneally, DMD, PA, a Maine professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jason D Lewis, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Ben Schultz, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Daniel Mirkin, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Nathan J Bonilla-Warford, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David C. Suh DDS, Inc., a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Nathan W Tilman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Visual Perceptions Vernon, LLC, a Connecticut limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Delmar Gray, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Brodedale Dental, PA, an Idaho professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Robert Lustbader, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David R Lach, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Luc E Kanicky, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

The Corbin Family Dental Arts, LLP, a New York limited liability partnership, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jeremy R Bayer, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Eric Barney, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Premier Dentistry, Inc., a Pennsylvania corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Richard Bruce, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Raymond C. Goodman, OD, PA, an Idaho professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Beth Snyder, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

BW Vision Care, PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Asheville Vision Associates OD PA, a North Carolina professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Lucy S Lee, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Michael W Domingoes, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Adnan Qayyum DDS LLC, a Pennsylvania limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

All About Smiles, Inc., a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Leonard F Tau, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Rodeffer, Garner & Minor Orthodontics, LC, a Florida limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Debra Glassman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Texarkan Vision Group, PLLC, a Texas company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Richard Pyun, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Fred R Shanks, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

J Philip Wiygul, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Richard Corbin, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Ira D Koeppel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Peter D. Maro, Jr., DMD MS, PC, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Lisa P Howard, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Steven A. Firshein DMD, Inc., a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Stephen M Montaquila, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Eric S. Smith, DDS, PC, a Utah professional company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Raymond Lawrence, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

North Shore Dental Arts, LLP, a New York limited liability partnership, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Joseph F Alvarez, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Larry J. Moray DDS MS PA, a New York professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Barry I Cohen, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Laura Vizzari, formerly known as Laura Reilly, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Raymond K Martin, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Gregory S Liss, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Raymond K. Martin DDS MAGD, PC, a Massachusetts professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Michael J Barbieri, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Gregg Fink DMD, Inc., a Delaware corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

John T Kalange, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Sajini Shetty DMD Dental Offices, PC, a New Hampshire professional company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Mirkins Vision Care, PC, a New York professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Robert R. Thousand, III, PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Samir K. Hanna & Associates, PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Gregory W Kalmar, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Signature Smiles, PC, a Georgia professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Coley & Coley Family Eyecare, Inc., a Tennessee corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David Alemar-Vincentry, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jason D. Lewis DDS PA, a Florida professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Kevin P Ryan, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Benjamin W Dreksler, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Handschumacher Enterprises, OD, PA, a North Carolina professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Joseph R Kenneally, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Farid Hanachi, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Kevin Wendell, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Tod Garner, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Anthony LaTempa DMD LLC, a New Jersey limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David R. Lach, D.D.S., M.S., P.A, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Value Vision of Tampa Bay, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Robert Aube, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Randall B Smith, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

John T Uetsuki, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Catherine M Ferentin, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Steven Glassman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Z. Maali Dental, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Ian Sobler, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

R Marc Carozza, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Lisa P. Howard, DDS, PC, a Maine professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Atul M. Patel, BDS, Inc., a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Charles Fitzpatrick, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

George Prattas, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Richard E. Sorkin OD, PA, a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Unique Dental Center, PC, a Massachusetts professional corporation, doing business as Unique Dental Care, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Gregg Fink, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Anthony LaTempa, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Nelson Eye Associates, PC, a New Jersey professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jeffrey Handschumacher, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Samir K Hanna, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David Goldberg, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Raymond C Goodman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Treva Diane Lee, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Lisa P. Howard, DDS, LLC, a Maine limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Adnan Qayyum, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Lucy S. Lee OD, PLLC, a Virginia professional limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Cedar Bluff Family & Cosmetic Dentistry, PA, a South Carolina professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

David C Suh, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Christine Nguyen, D.D.S., P.A., a Florida professional association, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Travis B Bartschi, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Paul M. Hertz DMD LLC, a New York limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

ATL Smiles, LLC, a Georgia limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Margaret Ames, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Michael Putt, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Serena Tham, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Atul M Patel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Ziyad Maali, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Ira D. Koeppel, PC, a New York professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jerry Strauss, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Nathan W. Tilman DDS, PC, a Rhode Island professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Sajini Shetty, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Wanda Arden, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Gray and Smith Family Dental, PC, an Idaho professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Fred R. Shanks OD, LLC, a Tennessee limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Kevin P. Ryan DDS, PC, an Illinois professional corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Lewis Family Dentistry, LLC, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Steven A Firshein, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Steven Wigdor O.D., P.A., a Florida Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group.

OD Steven Wigdor, also known as Steven Wigdor, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Radzwill Optometric Associates, Chartered, a florida Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Eric M Radzwill OD, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Coral Springs Eye Center, Chartered, a florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Steven R Koganovsky, O.D., individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Beville Dental Care, a corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Adriana Porter, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Eye Health & Vision Center, P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

David Rubin, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ivan Rosenthal, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Robert M. Easton Jr. O.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Robert Easton, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Vision Arts Eyecare Center, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Edward Walker, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

All Eyes Optical, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Vito Guario, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Marciano Family Optometric, P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Brandee Marciano, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kaufman Eyecare Center, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Sandford Kaufman, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

The Hour Glass, Inc., a Florida Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

James Stephens, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Mitchell A. Josephs, D.D.S., P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Mitchell Josephs, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Sandra Barker, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

New View Optometric Center, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Melvin Kasanoff, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jay Gelman, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Palm Beach Eyes of Boynton Beach, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Greg Pientka, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Bethany Brenner, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Palm Vision Center, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Steven Anhalt, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Barrera Optical, Inc., a Texas corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Mario Barrera, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Lori J. Bende, O.D., Professional Optometric Corp., a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Lori Bende, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Daniel Del Castillo, D.M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Daniel Del Castillo, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Gallinger, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Oakwood Dental Arts, LLC, a New York Limited Liability Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Emanuel Graziano, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alan Grossman, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Tad Kosanovich, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ragsdale & Martin Optical, Inc., a Texas corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael Martin, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Family Vision Center, P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Lori Mazza, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Advanced Dental Center of Summerville, PA, a South Carolina corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

James Muscott, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Peter Scerbo DMD, P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Peter Scerbo, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Raymond E. Schwartz, P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Raymond E Schwartz, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

E. Wayne Simmons, D.M.D. Prosthodontist, P.C., a Texas corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

E. Wayne Simmons, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Barry Simon, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Ronald N. Smith, Optometrist, Inc., a Texas corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ronald Smith, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Terry Van Der Heyden, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Advantage Family Vision Center, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Charles Porch, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fred Buettner, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael L. Grace, O.D., P.A., a Texas corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

20/20 Vision Clinic, LLP, a Texas limited liability partnership, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett & David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael Grace, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Blaisdell Dental Center, P.A., an Idaho corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John Blaisdell, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

James L. Carazola, D.M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

James Carazola, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Christopher S. Carroll, D.D.S., P.C., a Wisconsin corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Christopher Carroll, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Tryphose Charles, DMD, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

M. Cowan & Associates, D.D.S., P.A., corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael J. Fernandez, D.M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael Fernandez, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Cedarhurst Dental Office, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Howard Goldschein, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Grayhills, Mohip Dental & Associates of Wellington, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Laurence Grayhills, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Spex in the City, LLC, a Washington limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Mark Hamilton, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alan R. Heap, D.M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alan Heap, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Emerald West Family Dentistry, PLLC, an Idaho limited liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Chad Hess, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Richard M. Kernagis, D.M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Richard Kernagis, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

East Lyme Family & Cosmetic Dentistry, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joseph Palumbo, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Lakeside Family Dentistry, P.L., a Florida Limited Liability company, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Christopher Seppi, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joel E. Vaccarezza, DDS, P.A., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joel Vaccarezza, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Eyad Shehadeh, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Eyad Shehadeh, DDS, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Freedman & Haas, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Sharon Haas, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Edward B. Busch, DMD, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Edward Busch, individually also known as Edward J. Bush, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Keith A. Colwell, DDS, PC, an Iowa corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Keith Colwell, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Beautiful Smiles Dental Care, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Anthony Gulde, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Philip K. Haiman & Associates, P.A., a Florida Corporation other Sunrise Eye Care, Inc., Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Philip Haiman, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Roland Park Vision Services, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Bruce Hyatt, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Neelofar Khan, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Stephen Obrochta, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Wesley B. Smith, DDS, PA, a North Carolina corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Wesley Smith, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jeffrey Tweedy, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Antonio Barcias, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Eyes On The Bay, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Neil Elliot, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Rodrick Keener, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Premier Dental, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Align Orthodontics, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Sanjeev Sharma, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Elliott Stupp, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Family Dental Care, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Chanbo Sim, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Wade G. Winker, DDS, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Wade Winker, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Countryside Dental Associates, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael Ancona, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Matos's Growing Smiles, PA, a New Jersey corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Manuel Gonzalez, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Thomas Jacka, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alfred Johnson, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth A. Mogell, DMD, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Mogell, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John D. Sherer, DMD, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John Sherer, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Katy Periodontics Management, Inc., a Texas corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Timothy Hale, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Stephen Allison, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Falls Cosmetic Dental Center, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Samuel Chandy, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Behdad Omrani, individually, Consol Plaintiff, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Vijay Patel, an individual, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Frantz Backer, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Advanced Dentistry of New York PLLC, New York corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Benjamin Braziel, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Reza M Birjandi, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Sekhar Chakka, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Timothy J Delaney, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Timothy J Delaney DDS Inc, a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Stanley Dintcho, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Rex E Grizzle, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Ebenezer Johnson, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Drs Ebenezer and Rachel Johnson DDS Inc, corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Jaikrishnan R Kakanar, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Jaikrishnan R Kakanar DDS Inc, a California corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Ramesh Kothari, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Harold C McClendon, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Gregory A Stainer, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Gregory A Stainer MD FACS, a Professional Medical Corporation, organized in California, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Charles Smurthwaite, an individual doing business as Smile Quest Dental, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Krupakar Yeturu, an individual, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation, Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Robert S. Green , Green & Noblin, P.C..

Vijay Patel, an individual - Case No. 1:11-cv-20462-PAS, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Reza M. Birjandi DDS, a Professional Dental Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

David Browning, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Michael W Wells DDS Inc, a California Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Eye Center Optometrics, a Professional Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

William E Faulkner DDS Inc, a California Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Alfonzo D Gonzalez, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Alfonzo D. Gonzalez Dental Corporation, a California Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Sandhy A Hedge DDS Inc, a California Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Jose Lomboy, an individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Maricela Murillo, an Individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Dennis E Shamlian, an Individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Valery Sweeny, an Individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Valery Sweeny DDS, a Professional Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

J Foster Weems, an Individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

J Foster Weems DDS Inc, a California Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Paul J. Wesling OD, an Individual, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Paul J Wesling OD Inc, a California Corporation on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation & Nicole M. Catanzarite-Woodward , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Brican America, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Defendant, represented by Paul L. Orshan , Paul L. Orshan, P.A..

Brican America, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, Consol Defendant, represented by Elior Daniel Shiloh , Gordon & Rees, LLP & Ronald A. Giller , Gordon & Rees, LLP.

Brican Financial Services, LLC, Consol Defendant, represented by Paul L. Orshan , Paul L. Orshan, P.A..

Jean Francois Vincens, also known as Jeff Vincens, Consol Defendant, represented by Paul L. Orshan , Paul L. Orshan, P.A..

Jacques Lemacon, Consol Defendant, Pro Se.

Jacques Lemacon, Consol Defendant, represented by Paul L. Orshan , Paul L. Orshan, P.A..

Salvatore M DeCanio, Jr., Consol Defendant, represented by Jeff Tomberg , Tomberg & Halper, LLC.

Lifestyle of Vision, Inc., a Florida corporation, Consol Defendant, represented by Jeff Tomberg , Tomberg & Halper, LLC.

NCMIC Finance Corporation, doing business as Professional Solutions Financial Services, an Iowa corporation authorized to do business in Florida, Consol Defendant, represented by Philip A. Nemecek , Katten Muchin Rosenman, LLP, Bryan Arthur Powell , Hunton & Williams LLP - Atlanta, Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP, John Russell Kelso , Levey Filler Rodriguez Kelso & De Bianchi LLP, Lawrence J. Bracken, II , Hunton & Williams, Michael F. Gallagher , Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP, Michael I. Verde , Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP, Ryan J. Larsen , Katten Muchen Rosenman LLP & Sara Karubian , Katten Muchin LLP.

Obrochta Center for Dental Health Stephen P. Obrochta DDS, PA, a Florida corporation, Consol Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

PSFS 3 Corporation, an Iowa Corporation, Consol Defendant, represented by Philip A. Nemecek , Katten Muchin Rosenman, LLP, Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP & Ryan J. Larsen , Katten Muchen Rosenman LLP.

NCMIC and PSFS 3, Consol Defendant, represented by John Russell Kelso , Levey Filler Rodriguez Kelso & De Bianchi LLP & Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP.

Viso Lasik Medspas LLC, a Florida limited liability company, Consol Defendant, Pro Se.

Professional Solutions Financial Services, Consol Defendant, represented by Scott A. Resnik , Katten, Muchin & Rosenman, LLP.

PSF 3 Corporation, an Iowa Corporation, Consol Defendant, represented by Ryan J. Larsen , Katten Muchen Rosenman LLP & Sara Karubian , Katten Muchin LLP.

NCMIC Finance Corporation of California, a California corporation doing business as Professional Solutions Financial Services in California, Consol Defendant, represented by Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP, Ryan J. Larsen , Katten Muchen Rosenman LLP & Sara Karubian , Katten Muchin LLP.

De Lage Landen Financial Services Inc, a Michigan corporation, Consol Defendant, represented by C. Lawrence Holmes , Dilworth Paxson LLP & Patrick M. Northen , Dilworth Paxson LLP.

Brican America LLC, a Florida limited liability company, Consol Defendant, Pro Se.

Dr. Peter Blauzvern, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Dr. Michael Anacona, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Lori Bende, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. John Brown, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Edward Chermal, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Paul Clark, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Kenneth Dobson, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Alfred Johnson, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Kennth Mogell, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Frank Paletta, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Christopher Seppi, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Sanjeev Sharma, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Alan Baribeau, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Sandra Barker, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Bethany Brenner, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Fred Cloninger, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Kenneth Gallinger, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Emanuel Graziano, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Timothy Hale, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Mitchell Josephs, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Paul Mormon, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Darwin Mormon, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Rafael Palanganas, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Nicholas Papapetros, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Lisa M Peters, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Barry Rosenberg, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. David Rubin, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Chandy Samuel, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Peter Scerbo, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. John Sherer, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. E. Wayne Simmons, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Ronald Smith, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. David Sweeney, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Edward Walker, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Michael Williams, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Wade Winker, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dr. Ebenezer Johnson, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Dr. Reza Birjandi, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Dr. David Weigle, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Robert Alan Selig , Boone & Davis PA & Rowan Keenan , Keenan, Ciccitto & Associates.

Dr. John Foore, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Robert Alan Selig , Boone & Davis PA & Rowan Keenan , Keenan, Ciccitto & Associates.

Dr. Ryan Estelle, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Robert Alan Selig , Boone & Davis PA & Rowan Keenan , Keenan, Ciccitto & Associates.

Dr. Uri Elias, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Harvey D. Rogers .

Dr. Zalman Bacheikov, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Robert L. Switkes , Robert L. Switkes & Associates, P.A., Joshua Michael Entin , Entin & Della Fera, P.A., Mendy Halberstam , Jackson Lewis P.C. & Regina Franco-Murphey , Rosen Switkes & Entin PL.

Paul Wesling, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Richard Boerner, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Charles Smurthwaite, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Ebenezer Johnson, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Frantz Backer, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

J Foster Weems, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Reza Birjandi, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Steve Aivazian, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

NCMIC and PSFS 3, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP & Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP.

Alan Baribeau, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Clark, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Edward Chermol, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Francine Camporeale, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Dobson, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Justin Chien, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Aaron Collins, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Adelaida Guarin, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by

Terry Friedman, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Miffleton, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Donald Newman, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Flugrad, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Erick Gray, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Douglas Machiela, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jeffrey Klein, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joel David, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Albert Arcand, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John Brown, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gerry Casazza, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Robert Heinrich, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Mormon, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Enrico Core, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Norman Dery, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fredrick Cloninger, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Behdad Omrani, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

David Discher, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

NCMIC and PSFS 3, Counter Claimant, represented by John Russell Kelso , Levey Filler Rodriguez Kelso & De Bianchi LLP & Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP.

Frank Paletta, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Marc Flesher, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dirk Hagen, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fred Grimes, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Philippe Morisseau, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael W Wells, an individual, Counter Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Shaun Larsen, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Rasbornik, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Duey Handy, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alan Baribeau, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Clark, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Janiene Gresla, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Stephen G. Blank DDS, PA, a Florida professional association, Counter Defendant, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Edward Chermol, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Amir Khoshnevis, Counter Defendant, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jeffrey Riso, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Angel Lopez, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Rafael Palanganas, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Francine Camporeale, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Carmine Morreale, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Dobson, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Daniel Mashoof, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Lisa Peters, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ross Palioca, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Justin Chien, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Aaron Collins, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Pedro Mora-Rosa, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gilbert Principe, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Adelaida Guarin, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Terry Friedman, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Roarke Miller, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Richard Norman, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gregory Hom, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Barry Rosenberg, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Miffleton, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Donald Newman, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Flugrad, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Erick Gray, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Douglas Machiela, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jeffrey Klein, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Nicholas Papapetros, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joel David, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ali Sarkarzadeh, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Albert Arcand, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John Brown, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gerry Casazza, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Miguel Pulido, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Robert Heinrich, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Mormon, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Enrico Core, Counter Defendant, represented by

Norman Dery, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fredrick Cloninger, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Behdad Omrani, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

David Discher, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Frank Paletta, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Marc Flesher, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dirk Hagen, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fred Grimes, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Philippe Morisseau, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Shaun Larsen, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Duey Handy, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alan Baribeau, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Clark, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Janiene Gresla, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Edward Chermol, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Amir Khoshnevis, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Angel Lopez, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Rafael Palanganas, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Francine Camporeale, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Carmine Morreale, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Dobson, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Daniel Mashoof, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Justin Chien, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Aaron Collins, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Pedro Mora-Rosa, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Adelaida Guarin, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Terry Friedman, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Roarke Miller, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Richard Norman, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gregory Hom, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Barry Rosenberg, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Miffleton, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Donald Newman, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Flugrad, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Erick Gray, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Douglas Machiela, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jeffrey Klein, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Nicholas Papapetros, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joel David, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ali Sarkarzadeh, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Albert Arcand, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John Brown, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gerry Casazza, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Miguel Pulido, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Robert Heinrich, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Mormon, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Enrico Core, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Norman Dery, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fredrick Cloninger, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Behdad Omrani, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

David Discher, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

NCMIC and PSFS 3, Counter Claimant, represented by John Russell Kelso , Levey Filler Rodriguez Kelso & De Bianchi LLP & Catherine Magdalena Rodriguez , Filler Rodriguez, LLP.

Frank Paletta, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Marc Flesher, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Dirk Hagen, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fred Grimes, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Philippe Morisseau, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Michael W Wells, an individual, Counter Defendant, represented by Kenneth Joseph Catanzarite , Catanzarite Law Corporation.

Shaun Larsen, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Rasbornik, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Duey Handy, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Alan Baribeau, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Clark, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Janiene Gresla, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Stephen G. Blank DDS, PA, a Florida professional association, Counter Defendant, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Edward Chermol, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Amir Khoshnevis, Counter Defendant, represented by Ronald Pendl Gossett , Gossett & Gossett.

Jeffrey Riso, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Angel Lopez, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Rafael Palanganas, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Francine Camporeale, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Carmine Morreale, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Kenneth Dobson, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Daniel Mashoof, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Lisa Peters, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ross Palioca, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Justin Chien, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Aaron Collins, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Pedro Mora-Rosa, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gilbert Principe, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Adelaida Guarin, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Terry Friedman, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Roarke Miller, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Richard Norman, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gregory Hom, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Barry Rosenberg, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Miffleton, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Donald Newman, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

George Flugrad, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Erick Gray, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Douglas Machiela, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Jeffrey Klein, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Nicholas Papapetros, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Joel David, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Ali Sarkarzadeh, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Albert Arcand, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

John Brown, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Gerry Casazza, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Miguel Pulido, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Robert Heinrich, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Paul Mormon, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Enrico Core, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Norman Dery, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Fredrick Cloninger, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

Behdad Omrani, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.

David Discher, Counter Defendant, represented by David H. Charlip , Charlip Law Group, LLC.


FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

PATRICIA A. SEITZ, District Judge.

THIS MATTER is before the Court following a six-day bench trial. Based on the evidence at trial, the Court enters these findings of fact, see infra at pp. 6-44, and conclusions of law, see infra at pp. 44-63.

A. INTRODUCTION

Plaintiffs are dentists and optometrists who bought multimedia systems designed...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases