FENERJIAN v. NONG SHIM COMPANY, LTD

Case No. 13-cv-04115-WHO (DMR).

STEPHEN FENERJIAN, et al., Plaintiffs, v. NONG SHIM COMPANY, LTD, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, N.D. California.

March 15, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Stephen Fenerjian, Plaintiff, represented by Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP, Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Jeffrey S. Nobel , Izard Nobel LLP, pro hac vice, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Michael Stuart Strimling , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP, Nicole Anne Veno , Izard Nobel LLP, pro hac vice & Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice.

Rockman Company (USA), Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP, Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Gregory Bradley Linkh , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Manuel Juan Dominguez , Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll, pro hac vice, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice, Thomas C. Bright , Cera LLP & Christopher L. Lebsock , Hausfeld LLP.

M.T. Trading Corporation, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas C. Bright , Cera LLP, Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP, Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Manuel Juan Dominguez , Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll, pro hac vice, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP & Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice.

The Plaza Company, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher L. Lebsock , Hausfeld LLP, Gregory Bradley Linkh , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Lee Albert , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Michael P. Lehmann , Hausfeld LLP, Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP, Bonny E. Sweeney , Hausfeld LLP, Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Joshua L Crowell , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Lionel Z. Glancy , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Michael M. Goldberg , Goldberg Law PC, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice, Stephanie Yunjin Cho , Hausfeld LLP & Susan Gilah Kupfer , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP.

Eleanor Pelobello, Plaintiff, represented by Sydney J. Hall , Law Offices of Sydney Jay Hall, Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP, Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Nicole Anne Veno , Izard Nobel LLP.

Christina Nguyen, Plaintiff, represented by Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP, Byron Seho Ahn , Reich Radcliffe Kuttler LLP, Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Marc Gene Reich , Reich Radcliffe and Kuttler LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP & Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice.

Anthony An, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Gerald S. Ohn , Law Offices of Gerald S. Ohn, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice, Young Wook Ryu , Law Office of Young W. Ryu APC & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Karen Heiferman, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Jill Bonnington, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Charles Chung, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Nicholas Halloran, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Kenny Kang, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Gerald S. Ohn , Law Offices of Gerald S. Ohn, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice, Young Wook Ryu , Law Office of Young W. Ryu APC & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Cynthia Skinner, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Ji Choi, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Joyce Beamer, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Yim Ha Noble, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Kendal Martin, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Thu-Thuy Nguyen, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

California Market LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Gregory Bradley Linkh , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Pitco Foods, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Gregory Bradley Linkh , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

The Plaza Market, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Gregory Bradley Linkh , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice, Stephanie Yunjin Cho , Hausfeld LLP, Susan Gilah Kupfer , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Summit Import Corp., Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Edward Birkhaeuser , Bramson, Plutzik, Mahler & Birkhaeuser LLP, Gregory Bradley Linkh , Glancy Prongay & Murray LLP, Mark P. Kindall , Izard Nobel LLP, Robert A. Izard , Izard Nobel, LLP, pro hac vice & Alan R. Plutzik , Bramson Plutzik Mahler & Birkhaeuser, LLP.

Nong Shim Company, Ltd, Defendant, represented by Anne Choi Goodwin , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, Edward Ghiyun Kim , Squire Patton Boggs, pro hac vice, J. Brady Dugan , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, pro hac vice, Joon Yong Kim , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, pro hac vice, Kate E Kim , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, pro hac vice & Mark C. Dosker , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP.

Nongshim America, Inc., Defendant, represented by Mark C. Dosker , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, Anne Choi Goodwin , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, Edward Ghiyun Kim , Squire Patton Boggs, pro hac vice, J. Brady Dugan , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, pro hac vice, Joon Yong Kim , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, pro hac vice & Kate E Kim , Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP, pro hac vice.

Ottogi Company, Ltd., Defendant, represented by Joel Steven Sanders , Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Lindsey Elizabeth Haswell , Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher & Minae Yu , Gibson Dunn and Crutcher.

Ottogi America, Inc., Defendant, represented by George Arnold Nicoud, III , Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Joel Steven Sanders , Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Lindsey Elizabeth Haswell , Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher & Minae Yu , Gibson Dunn and Crutcher.

SamYang Foods Company, Ltd., Defendant, represented by Elizabeth Dianne Mann , Mayer Brown LLP & Justin Robert Dickerson , Mayer Brown LLP.

Sam Yang (U.S.A.), Inc., Defendant, represented by Edward W. Suh , Law Offices of Michael K. Suh and Associates & Michael Kwonchun Suh , Law Offices of Michael K. Suh and Associates.

Korea Yakult, doing business as Paldo America, Defendant, represented by Matthew David Taggart , Attorney at Law.

Paldo Company, Ltd., Defendant, represented by Seong H. Kim , Steptoe and Johnson LLP, Edward B. Schwartz , DLA Piper US LLP, pro hac vice & Matthew David Taggart , Attorney at Law.


ORDER RE JOINT DISCOVERY LETTERS Re: Dkt. No. 297, 312.

Before the court are two joint discovery letters that raise three issues. Defendants Ottogi Corporation, Ltd., Ottogi America, Inc., Nongshim Co., Ltd. and Nongshim America, Inc. (collectively, "Defendants") move to compel eight Indirect Purchaser...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases