IN RE EXPRESS SCRIPTS, INC.

Case No. 4:05MD01672HEA.

In re EXPRESS SCRIPTS, INC., PBM LITIGATION. This Document Relates to: NPA-ERISA Track Cases Only Lanigan as Trustee on Behalf of Local 153 Health Fund v. Express Scripts, Inc., et al. Case No. 4:05CV862.

United States District Court, E.D. Missouri, Eastern Division.

January 8, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

In Re Express Scripts, Inc., represented by William I. Sussman , ROPES AND GRAY LLP.

Richard Mixon, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher P. Ridout , RIDOUT AND LYON, LLP, David R. Buchanan , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C., David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Jay B. Angoff , MEHRI AND SKALET PLLC, Leonard A. Davis , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Mike Miller , SOLBERG AND STEWART, Paul A. Koerber , PAUL A. KOERBER, Roger G. Brown , ROGER G. BROWN AND ASSOCIATES, Russ M. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, Stacey E. Tjon Bossart , SOLBERG AND STEWART, Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Stephen F. Meyerkord , MEYERKORD AND MEYERKORD, LLC & Wm. Michael Gruenloh , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Sam Clay, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher P. Ridout , RIDOUT AND LYON, LLP, David R. Buchanan , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C., David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Jay B. Angoff , MEHRI AND SKALET PLLC, Leonard A. Davis , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Mike Miller , SOLBERG AND STEWART, Paul A. Koerber , PAUL A. KOERBER, Roger G. Brown , ROGER G. BROWN AND ASSOCIATES, Russ M. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, Stacey E. Tjon Bossart , SOLBERG AND STEWART, Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Stephen F. Meyerkord , MEYERKORD AND MEYERKORD, LLC & Wm. Michael Gruenloh , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Karen Cameron, Plaintiff, represented by David R. Buchanan , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C., David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Jay B. Angoff , MEHRI AND SKALET PLLC, Leonard A. Davis , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Mike Miller , SOLBERG AND STEWART, Paul A. Koerber , PAUL A. KOERBER, Roger G. Brown , ROGER G. BROWN AND ASSOCIATES, Russ M. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, Stacey E. Tjon Bossart , SOLBERG AND STEWART, Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Stephen F. Meyerkord , MEYERKORD AND MEYERKORD, LLC, Wm. Michael Gruenloh , MOTLEY RICE LLC & Christopher P. Ridout , RIDOUT AND LYON, LLP.

Patrick J. Lynch, Plaintiff, represented by Anthony J. Sievert , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, Brian L. Williams , HEINS AND MILLS, PLC, Kenneth A. Wexler , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, Marc H. Edelson , EDELSON AND ASSOCIATES, LLC, Samuel D. Heins , HEINS AND MILLS, PLC, Thomas M. Sobol , HAGENS AND BERMAN, LLP, William H. Narwold , MOTLEY RICE & David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Steven Powell, Plaintiff, represented by Amber M. Nesbitt , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Jeffrey J. Corrigan , SPECTOR AND ROSEMAN, P.C., Kenneth A. Wexler , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP & Lee Squitieri , SQUITIERI AND FEARON LLP.

Brian Jordan, Plaintiff, represented by Amber M. Nesbitt , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, Jeffrey J. Corrigan , SPECTOR AND ROSEMAN, P.C., Kenneth A. Wexler , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP & Lee Squitieri , SQUITIERI AND FEARON LLP.

James V. Morgan, Plaintiff, represented by Amber M. Nesbitt , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, Jeffrey J. Corrigan , SPECTOR AND ROSEMAN, P.C., Kenneth A. Wexler , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP & Lee Squitieri , SQUITIERI AND FEARON LLP.

John Dougherty, Plaintiff, represented by Amber M. Nesbitt , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, Jeffrey J. Corrigan , SPECTOR AND ROSEMAN, P.C., Kenneth A. Wexler , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP & Lee Squitieri , SQUITIERI AND FEARON LLP.

Kenneth R. Boyd, Plaintiff, represented by Amber M. Nesbitt , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, Jeffrey J. Corrigan , SPECTOR AND ROSEMAN, P.C., Kenneth A. Wexler , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP & Lee Squitieri , SQUITIERI AND FEARON LLP.

Terry Kramer, Plaintiff, represented by Amber M. Nesbitt , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP, Jeffrey J. Corrigan , SPECTOR AND ROSEMAN, P.C., Kenneth A. Wexler , WEXLER WALLACE, LLP & Lee Squitieri , SQUITIERI AND FEARON LLP.

Central Laborers' Welfare Fund, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher M. Burke , ROBBINS AND GELLER, LLP, Edith M. Kallas , WHATLEY AND DRAKE, John R. Patchett , PATCHETT LAW FIRM, John J. Stoia, Jr. , LERACH AND COUGHLIN, Joseph P. Guglielmo , MILBERG LLP, Rachel L. Jensen , LERACH AND COUGHLIN, Rachel Wintterle , MILBERG LLP & Joy Annemarie Nesbitt , MILBERG LLP.

William E. Scheuerman, Plaintiff, represented by Amy J. Lepine , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Mark L. Knutson , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Phillip H. Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Amy J. Lepine , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

John J. Marino, Plaintiff, represented by Amy J. Lepine , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Jerome P. Brown, Union Officer Trustee, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Ingrid L. Moll , MOTLEY RICE LLC, Leonard A. Davis , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Maury A. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, William H. Narwold , MOTLEY RICE LLC & Wm. Michael Gruenloh , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Paul Heffernan, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, Ingrid L. Moll , MOTLEY RICE LLC & Leonard A. Davis , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Paul Heffernan, Fund, Plaintiff, represented by Maury A. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP & Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Paul Heffernan, Plaintiff, represented by William H. Narwold , MOTLEY RICE & Wm. Michael Gruenloh , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Correction Officers' Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Robert M. Kornreich , WOLF AND POPPER, LLP, Chet B. Waldman , WOLF AND POPPER, LLP & David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

James M. Wagner, Plaintiff, represented by Adam R. Gonnelli , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP, Amy J. Lepine , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Beth Keller , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP, Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Mark L. Knutson , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Michael Vachon , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Jan Gorsky, Plaintiff, represented by Adam R. Gonnelli , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP, Amy J. Lepine , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Beth Keller , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP, Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Michael Vachon , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Marilyn Dickert, Plaintiff, represented by Adam R. Gonnelli , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP, Amy J. Lepine , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Beth Keller , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP, Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Michael Vachon , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Rosa Maria Castillo Kesper, Plaintiff, represented by Adam R. Gonnelli , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP, Amy J. Lepine , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP, Beth Keller , FARUQI AND FARUQI, LLP & Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Rosa Maria Castillo Kesper, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Vachon , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Local 153 Health Fund, Plaintiff, represented by Evan D. Buxner , WALTHER/ZWIBELMAN LAW ASSOCIATES, Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Mark L. Knutson , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Kathy Minshew, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Kathy Minshew, Plaintiff, represented by Maury A. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Kathy Minshew, Plaintiff, represented by Ronald S. Goldser , ZIMMERMAN REED P.L.L.P., Stacey E. Tjon Bossart , SOLBERG AND STEWART, Stacy K. Hauer , ZIMMERMAN REED P.L.L.P., Timothy J. Becker , ZIMMERMAN REED P.L.L.P., Andrea S. Hirsch , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP & Stephen J. Herman , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Fidelity Benefit Administrators, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by David A. Rosen , RIDOUT AND LYON, LLP, Mathew P. Jasinski , MOTLEY RICE LLC & William H. Narwold , MOTLEY RICE.

Fidelity Insurance Co., Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP, David A. Rosen , RIDOUT AND LYON, LLP, Mathew P. Jasinski , MOTLEY RICE LLC & William H. Narwold , MOTLEY RICE.

Kenneth Brynien, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP & Mark L. Knutson , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Arlea J. Igoe, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey R. Krinsk , FINKELSTEIN AND KRINSK, LLP.

Food Employers Labor Relations Association and United Food and Commerical Workers Health and Welfare Fund, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

C. James Lowthers, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Washington Wholesalers Health and Welfare Fund, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

United Food and Commercial Workers Health and Welfare Fund of Northeastern Pennsylvania, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Max Bruny, Plaintiff, represented by David A. McKay , HERMAN AND MATHIS, LLP.

Express Scripts, Inc., Defendant, represented by Angela S. Quinn , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Brien T. O'Connor , ROPES AND GRAY LLP, Christopher G. Barnes , JORDEN BURT, LLP, Christopher J. Valeriote , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Daniel J. Maher , ROPES AND GRAY LLP, Jayma M. Meyer , SIMPSON AND THACHER, LLP, Jeanine R. Bermel , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Jeffrey L. Williams , JORDEN BURT, LLP, Joseph P. Conran , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Kenneth R. Logan , SIMPSON AND THACHER, LLP, Mark G. Arnold , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Michael P. Nolan , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Michael A. Valerio , JORDEN BURT, LLP, Omri E. Praiss , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Richard D. Batchelder , ROPES AND GRAY LLP, Susan E. Brown , ROPES AND GRAY LLP, Thomas M. Dee , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, William I. Sussman , ROPES AND GRAY LLP, Christopher A. Smith , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, David J. Przygoda , ROPES AND GRAY, LLP, Harry B. Wilson , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP & Lee S. Gayer , ROPES AND GRAY, LLP.

ESI Mail Pharmacy Service, Inc., Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Conran , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Omri E. Praiss , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Brien T. O'Connor , ROPES AND GRAY LLP, David J. Przygoda , ROPES AND GRAY, LLP, Lee S. Gayer , ROPES AND GRAY, LLP & William I. Sussman , ROPES AND GRAY LLP.

Express Scripts Utilization Management Co., Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Conran , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP, Lee S. Gayer , ROPES AND GRAY, LLP & Omri E. Praiss , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company, The, Movant, represented by James C. Hetlage , LASHLY AND BAER, P.C. & Margaret M. Mooney , LASHLY AND BAER, P.C..

Lidia Garcia, Movant, represented by Don R. Lolli , DYSART AND TAYLOR.


OPINION, MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

HENRY EDWARD AUTREY, District Judge.

This matter is before the Court on Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification [Doc. No. 426]. A Class Certification Hearing has been conducted in the matter and the motion has been briefed and argued. For the reasons set forth below, the Motion for Class Certification is denied.

FACTS AND BACKGROUND

The current posture of this Multi-District litigation...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases