CAMPBELL v. ABB INC.

Case No. 4:14CV01489 AGF.

CHARLES CAMPBELL, SR., et al., Plaintiffs, v. ABB INC., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. Missouri, Eastern Division.

March 5, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Charles Campbell, SR., Plaintiff, represented by Ryan P. Horace , NAPOLI AND BERN & Sean Patrick Barth , NAPOLI AND BERN.

Lena Campbell, Plaintiff, represented by Ryan P. Horace , NAPOLI AND BERN & Sean Patrick Barth , NAPOLI AND BERN.

ABB Inc., formerly known as Asea Brown Boveri, Inc. formerly known as Brown Boveri Electric Co., Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, also known as Buffalo Pumps, Inc., Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, formerly known as The Glidden Company, Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

CBS Corporation, formerly known as Viacom, Inc., Successor by Merger to CBS Corp. formerly known as Westinghouse Electric Corp, Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael R. Dauphin , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually Successor In Interest Crouse-Hinds Company PPB, Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Eaton Corporation, individually and as Successor In Interest Cutler Hammer, Inc., Defendant, represented by J. Todd Applegate , PITZER SNODGRASS, P.C. & Brian J. Connolly , REEG LAWYERS, LLC.

Ericsson, Inc., Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

FMC Corporation, individually Successor In Interest Northern Pump Company Successor In Interest Coffin Successor In Interest Chicago Pump Company Successor In Interest Peerless, Defendant, represented by Marcie J. Vantine , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Graybar Electric Company, Inc., Defendant, represented by Jeffrey T. Bash , LEWIS AND BRISBOIS, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., formerly known as Alliedsignal, Inc. formerly known as The Bendix Corporation, Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

IMO Industries Inc., Defendant, represented by Matthew R. Fields , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C. & Matthew David Bigham , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C..

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Raypak, Inc., a Wholly Owned Subisdiary of Rheem Manufacturing Co., Defendant, represented by Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Earl B. Thames , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Co., Defendant, represented by Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Earl B. Thames , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., formerly known as Allen Bradley Company Inc. Successor In Interest Rostone Corporation, Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, formerly known as Square D Co., Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P., Michael R. Dauphin , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Young Group Ltd., formerly known as Young Sales Corp., Defendant, represented by Jordan K. Pack , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

Young Insulation Group of St. Louis, Inc., Defendant, represented by Jordan K. Pack , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

Cooper Industries, LLC, 600 Travis Street #5800 Houston, TX 77002-3008, Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP.

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Crane Co., Cross Claimant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP.

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Graybar Electric Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey T. Bash , LEWIS AND BRISBOIS, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP.

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Graybar Electric Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey T. Bash , LEWIS AND BRISBOIS, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Claimant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

IMO Industries Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew R. Fields , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C..

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

John Crane Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Amy K. Shasserre , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P., Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P., Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS & Robert J. Brummond , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

John Crane Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

ABB Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Carrier Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Certainteed Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Counter Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Counter Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Counter Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

IMO Industries Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Matthew David Bigham , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C..

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Counter Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

John Crane Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

Johnson Controls, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Counter Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Counter Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

John Crane Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael R. Dauphin , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael R. Dauphin , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Graybar Electric Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey T. Bash , LEWIS AND BRISBOIS, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

John Crane Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

IMO Industries Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Matthew R. Fields , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C..

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael R. Dauphin , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Graybar Electric Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey T. Bash , LEWIS AND BRISBOIS, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

IMO Industries Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew R. Fields , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C..

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

John Crane Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Raypak, Inc., a Wholly Owned Subisdiary of Rheem Manufacturing Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Earl B. Thames , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Earl B. Thames , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Claimant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

ABB Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Akzo Nobel Paints LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Jacob Hurtt, Jr. , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.

Belden Wire & Cable Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc., Successor by Merger to Borg-Warner Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael R. Dauphin , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Certainteed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER & Kent L. Plotner , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Cooper Technologies Company, individually, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica L. Prosperi , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin John Wilson , HEPLER BROOM & Carl J. Geraci , HEPLER BROOM.

Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

DAP, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Ericsson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Megan Ashley Schwarz , SEGAL AND MCCAMBRIDGE.

General Cable Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anita Maria Kidd , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE, LLP.

Graybar Electric Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey T. Bash , LEWIS AND BRISBOIS, LLP.

Hanson Permanente Cement, Cross Defendant, represented by Virginia M. Giokaris , RASMUSSEN AND WILLIS.

Honeywell International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC & Dennis J. Dobbels , POLSINELLI PC.

IMO Industries Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew R. Fields , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C. & Matthew David Bigham , JACOBSON AND PRESS, P.C..

J.P. Bushnell Packing Supply Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen J. Maassen , HOAGLAND AND FITZGERALD.

John Crane Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Albert J. Bronsky , BROWN AND JAMES, P.C..

Johnson Controls, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Lennox Industries, Inc. Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles L. Joley , JOLEY AND OLIVER.

Pneumo Abex, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Mary Dianne Rychnovsky , Williams Venker & Sanders LLC, Matthew E. Pelikan , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC, Ross S. Titzer , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC & Thomas L. Orris , WILLIAMS AND VENKER, LLC.

Raypak, Inc., a Wholly Owned Subisdiary of Rheem Manufacturing Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Earl B. Thames , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Earl B. Thames , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Robertson Ceco Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory C. Flatt , HEYL AND ROYSTER.

Rockwell Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

Schneider Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony L. Springfield , POLSINELLI PC.

Sears Roebuck & Co., a subsidiary of Sears Holdings Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by April A. Vesely , SWANSON AND MARTIN, LLP & Paul W. Lore .

Siemens Energy & Automation, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas W. Hayes , MCKENNA STORER.

Simpson Timber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel G. Donahue , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P. & Michael W. Newport , FOLEY AND MANSFIELD, P.L.L.P..

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M. Valentino , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ, Jerry S. Warchol , KUROWSKI SHULTZ LLC, Lacy M. Fields , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ & Lindsay A. Dibler , KUROWSKI SCHULTZ.

The Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Bruegger , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP & Tracy J. Cowan , HAWKINS AND PARNELL, LLP.

Welco Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP.

York International Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James D. Maschhoff , HERZOG CREBS LLP, Mary A. Hatch , HERZOG CREBS LLP & Tracy Beckman Phipps , HERZOG CREBS LLP.


MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

Plaintiffs initially filed this action in the Circuit Court of St. Louis County, Missouri, asserting that Plaintiff Charles Campbell, Sr., has contracted lung cancer as a result of his exposure to asbestos over a 55 year period in different locations across the country. Defendants...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases