1. Identity Wars:
the End of Human Society
How internet culture challenges
the identity mappings
that human society depends on.
Christian Heller / plomlompom
2009-12-29
c-base, Berlin, Germany
2. overview
â—Ź Top-Down-Imposition of Identities
â—Ź Self-Imposition of Identities
â—Ź Liberty of Identities
â—Ź The Forging/Crafting of the Individual
â—Ź The Dissolution of the Individual
â—Ź Enter the Borganism
3. life: original nameless viriditas
„Stro
m
petri atolites,
fie t
in the d biofilm hat is pre
-
Glac Siyeh roc about on cambrian
ie k e
http: r Nationa formatio billion ye
//en. ars o
wikip l Park, M n of ld
edia. onta
org/w n
iki/Fi a, USA.“
le:St
roma
tolite
s.jpg
4. life: original nameless viriditas
â—Ź life force evolutionarily permeates the universe
● chaotical start, without „order“ / taxonomy
â—Ź no purpose, no interest, no identity: no politics
â—Ź structures and differentiates itself into organical
hierarchies and networks
● diversities of micro-machines → diversities of cells
compose diversities of plants/animals/etc. …
â—Ź all interacting with each other in many complex
ways, not one clear hierarchy
5. societies: made up of people
Frontispiece to Thomas Hobbes' „Leviathan“ by Abraham Bosse, 1651
6. societies: made up of people
â—Ź differentiated into hierarchies of:
â—Ź discrete animal units (human individuals) and
â—Ź superorganisms (societies) made up of
configurations of these
â—Ź determined taxonomically by a symbolic
intelligence; orderly
7. peoples, cultures, nations, states
„John Bull and his Friends by Fred W Rose, 1900“
Uploaded by peacay / Paul K, Licence: CC-BY-2.0
http://www.flickr.com/photos/bibliodyssey/3668664529/
8. peoples, cultures, nations, states
â—Ź identitary nature of social superorganisms
â—Ź peoples, cultures, nations, states, organized
religions, classes, guilds/unions, political parties,
gender?, ...
â—Ź superhuman superorganisms != free
memeplexes
â—Ź strive for stability
â—Ź often strive for clear borders
â—Ź their relations are powerful and political
9. superorganisms imposing identity
„ID card in Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia – 1943“
Author: „scanned by Krokodyl“, Licence: CC-BY-3.0 Unported
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Protektoratni_obcanka_1943.jpg
10. superorganisms imposing identity
â—Ź credentials (by the state, the club, the guild, the
university): ID card, membership, certificates
â—Ź legal identification and accountability
â—Ź cultural education
● „Gleichschaltung“ organically downwards
â—Ź authoritarian identity lock-ins
â—Ź Behave according to your identity!
â—Ź Your identity is what I say it is! (By order of God,
Nature, History, Society.)
13. citizen / citoyen
â—Ź subjective internalization of, identification with
society; pride
â—Ź strong identification with superorganism, but
bottom-up; responsible, creative
shareholdership
â—Ź illusion (!) of responsibility for identity (e.g.
nationality, education hardly ever freely chosen)
â—Ź top-down vs bottom-up: yet another political
power struggle
14. „Vitruvian Man“ by Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Da_Vinci_Vitruve_Luc_Viatour.jpg
humanism and personalism
„Bildnis der Mutter“, Albrecht Dürer (1471–1528)
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:DĂĽrer_-_Bildnis_der_Mutter.jpg
15. humanism and personalism
â—Ź individual personality
â—Ź Christianity: absolute human dignity, equality,
incommensurability; Human Rights
â—Ź glorifying, romanticizing the individuals, their
inner selves and their relations
â—Ź individual human ego as the new bottleneck for
identity
â—Ź (previously: the upper superorganic hierarchies)
16. „Werther aus Die Leiden des Jungen Werthers“ ( Author: Chodowiecki
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:WertherAusDieLeiden
DesJungenWerthersZeichnungChodowiecki.jpg
The Individual Identity
„L1001521“ / Author: Guido van Nispen
License: CC-BY-2.0
http://www.flickr.com/photos/vannispen/3232494530/
17. The Individual Identity
â—Ź complex society with conflicting guidelines for
behaviour →
â—Ź individual identity as the necessary new guiding
scheme
â—Ź identity = responsibility
â—Ź create your own identitary, biographical
narrative of goals, guilts, bindings
â—Ź draw on available identity resources
â—Ź not the same choices available for everyone
18. the fight for identitarian diversity
„San Francisco Pride Parade“ / Author: Jere Keys
License: CC-BY-2.0
http://www.flickr.com/photos/tyreseus/2623090047/
19. the fight for identitarian diversity
â—Ź broaden the inventory of identity resources
â—Ź broaden the social acceptance of certain
identities in existing spaces
â—Ź create new spaces accepting certain identities
32. empowering identitarian liberty?
â—Ź multiplication of identity resources
â—Ź endless space for every imaginable identity
â—Ź new socialities for identities give strengthening
social feedback
â—Ź traditional identity bottlenecks get goatsed
34. identitarian bottleneck incongruities
â—Ź acceptance of imposed identity bottlenecks
diminishes
â—Ź choose the democracy that votes your way
â—Ź have your cake and eat it, too
â—Ź superorganisms lose control over flow of
identity resources in their territory
â—Ź loss of common background, socialization
â—Ź digital globalization and its discontents
â—Ź how to block? censorship? national internet?
36. „politics 2.0“ (for real)
â—Ź citizenships in superorganisms that surpass the
size of most states, languages, religions
â—Ź Facebook: 350.000.000, MySpace: 100.000.000
â—Ź USA: 300.000.000, German language: 200.000.000
â—Ź Judaism: 13.000.000
â—Ź non-binding, multiple citizenships
â—Ź freedom of movement
37. „politics 2.0“ (for real)
Screenshots
from sign-up dialogue
of FetLife.com
(300.000 members)
39. reality of new identity structures
â—Ź internet communities provide basic structure for
identity, communication, action
â—Ź importance is ever growing
â—Ź 'digital' identity not much more artifical than the
'real' one
41. dissolution of individual integrity
â—Ź open-sourcing of identity
â—Ź fake accounts, fake interpersonality of interactions
â—Ź identitarian chat and twitter bots
â—Ź post-private information overload destroys
illusion of coherent personality
â—Ź loss of individual predictability and responsibility
42. „Anonymous. Only 1000 of them. No more.“ / Author: Anonymous
http://encyclopediadramatica.com/Image:Bdespairanonymous1000ks2.png
44. humanistic / personalistic racism
â—Ź prove your humanity!
â—Ź forced registration, identification, login
â—Ź one account only for one e-mail address!
â—Ź map everything to legally seizable social units
â—Ź surveillance for identification
● data retention laws / „Vorratsdatenspeicherung“
46. information politics?
â—Ź new legal persons?
â—Ź citizen rights and responsibilities for bot nets,
fake accounts, borganisms, memes ...?
â—Ź problems: non-binding, transient nature of new
identity patterns
â—Ź new legal bottlenecks will get bypassed quickly:
new structures grow faster