1. Home
  2. Browse Decisions
  3. HENDRICH v. MEDTRONIC, INC.
 

HENDRICH v. MEDTRONIC, INC.

Case No. 4:14CV01635 AGF.

JIMMY HENDRICH, et al., Plaintiffs, v. MEDTRONIC, INC., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. Missouri, Eastern Division.

November 5, 2014.

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Jimmy Hendrich, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Loretta Ann Hendrich, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Karen Klaseus, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Vincent Adderly, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Yuksel Agan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Victor Baez, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Floyd Barnett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Barry Black, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Sabrina Black, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Stephen Bolduc, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Arlene Bolduc, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Julia Boynton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

David Burroughs, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Stephanie Campbell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Vivian Cannon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Jennifer Coy-Cannon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Wilbert Carlton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Raymond Champagne, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Steven Crenshaw, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Debra Derosier, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Wesner Derosier, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Maryann Deves, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

David Deves, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Boris Fraley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Ruth Fraley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Joseph Frederick, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Kathleen Gresser, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Edris Hicks, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Gordon High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Jennifer Lynn High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Matthew Horswill, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Jeweleen Horswill, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Carol James, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Shaunta Kemp, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Karl Kent, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Caroline Brown Kent, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Douglas Kiffmeyer, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Charles Lee, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Lisa Ann Lee, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Alonzo Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Brenda Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Stephen Lindsey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Dawn Matlock, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Johanna Maynard, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Debra McClurkin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Joseph McClurkin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Andrea Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Wyndi Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Frank Mills, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Lola Mills, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Michael Nedo, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Lenore Lofaro, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

John Ockleston, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

James Oliver, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Edward Salsman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Alberto Sanchez, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Iris Sanchez, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

James Severin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Jodi Severin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Melissa Shackleford, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Ricky Shackleford, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Melanie Shaw, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Charles Shaw, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Heather Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

June Spomer, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Debra Strickland, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Tammy Thomas, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Mark Thomas, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Patsy Thompson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Stephen Thompson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Martin Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Donna Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Steve Wilson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Laura Wolfe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

George Atchison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Ruth Ann Atchison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Douglas Bergeron, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Sylvia Bryant, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Lester Bryant, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

San Juanita Cantu Flores, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Bryan Keith Freeman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Stanley Grove, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Jacqueline Grove, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Ted Jakovec, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Marian Jakovec, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Sharon Little, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Robby Michael Orderon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Teralandur Parthasarathy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Gita Malur, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Keith Schremp, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Mary Ann Tillman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

David Tillman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Carlos Webster, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Holland , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C. & Randall S. Crompton , HOLLAND AND GROVES, L.L.C..

Medtronic Inc, Defendant, represented by John Elliot Gibbons , BUCKLEY AND BUCKLEY, L.L.C., Martin J. Buckley , BUCKLEY AND BUCKLEY, L.L.C. & Murray S. Levin , PEPPER HAMILTON, LLP.

Medtronic Sofamor Danek USA, Inc., Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Tauber , MAYER BROWN LLP, Daniel L. Ring , MAYER BROWN LLP, John Elliot Gibbons , BUCKLEY AND BUCKLEY, L.L.C., Martin J. Buckley , BUCKLEY AND BUCKLEY, L.L.C., Murray S. Levin , PEPPER HAMILTON, LLP & Sean P. Fahey , PEPPER HAMILTON LLP.

Medtronic Sofamor Danek, Inc., Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Tauber , MAYER BROWN LLP, Daniel L. Ring , MAYER BROWN LLP, Martin J. Buckley , BUCKLEY AND BUCKLEY, L.L.C. & Sean P. Fahey , PEPPER HAMILTON LLP.

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

AUDREY G. FLEISSIG, District Judge.

This matter comes before the Court on Plaintiffs' motion to remand for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. (Doc. No. 11.) For the reasons set forth below, Plaintiffs' motion shall be granted.

BACKGROUND

On May 29, 2014, Plaintiffs filed this tort action in the Twenty-Second Judicial Circuit Court of Missouri, located in the City of St...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases